Supreme Court Orders War Injury Pension for Ex-Subedar Major Devi Singh After Accidental Own-Weapon Wound on Duty

0 Comments
Supreme Court Orders War Injury Pension for Ex-Subedar Major Devi Singh After Accidental Own-Weapon Wound on Duty

The Supreme Court has ruled that an Army veteran injured when his own service weapon accidentally discharged during operational duty is eligible for the higher War Injury Element of pension. The Court said the fact that the bullet came from the soldier’s weapon does not, by itself, make the injury “self-inflicted”.

A Bench of Justices Satish Chandra Sharma and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh allowed the appeal filed by JC-377745M Ex Subedar Major and Honorary Lieutenant Devi Singh, setting aside decisions of the Armed Forces Tribunal’s Regional Bench in Lucknow. It directed the Union of India to sanction and pay the War Injury Element under Regulation 103 of the Pension Regulations for the Army from the date of Singh’s retirement, after adjusting the ordinary Disability Element already paid. The revised Pension Payment Order (PPO) and net arrears must be issued and paid within three months.

Injury during operational duty

Singh joined the Indian Army on 24 June 1985 and retired on 31 March 2019 as Subedar Major and Honorary Lieutenant, following 33 years of service. On 7 August 2002, while serving with 31 Sub Area Signal Company in Jammu and Kashmir during Operation Rakshak/Operation Parakram, his loaded service weapon accidentally discharged. The bullet passed through his left thigh and damaged the femoral vein.

The injury left Singh with a permanent disability assessed at 40 per cent for life, rounded to 50 per cent for pension purposes. The Release Medical Board found the injury attributable to military service. Singh received the ordinary Disability Element, but his claim for the higher War Injury Element was denied.

The Armed Forces Tribunal rejected his claim, relying principally on the absence of final approval from the Adjutant General’s Branch (MP-5), the fact that Singh’s name was missing from a later digital database, and the loss of original Court of Inquiry and unit records. Those records had been destroyed in the 2014 floods while in official custody.

Why the Court accepted the claim

The Supreme Court found that the surviving official documents were sufficient to establish the circumstances of the injury and its connection to the operation. Part II Order No. BC-59, dated 16 December 2002, was headed “Battle Casualty Wound Op Rakshak Op Parakram” and recorded a gunshot wound sustained on duty. The Court considered it alongside subsequent Entitlement Cards and a Battle Casualty/Attributability Certificate issued by Signals Records.

Taken together, the records established the operational link with Operation Rakshak/Parakram and brought the injury within Category ‘E’, specifically clause (h), of Regulation 82. That category covers injuries sustained in action against extremists or anti-social elements.

Addressing the argument that the injury was self-inflicted, the Bench drew a distinction between an accidental injury caused by a serviceman’s own weapon and deliberate self-harm. “The exclusion is of a self-inflicted injury, not of every injury in which a serviceman’s own weapon happens to be the source of the bullet,” it said.

The Court observed that owning or carrying a weapon does not establish an intention to cause injury. An accidental discharge may result from an impact or fall, a trigger snagging, inadvertent pressure or a mechanical defect. Those circumstances, it said, are distinct from deliberate self-harm, which requires knowledge or intention.

The Bench also referred to Army Order 1/2003/MP, which expressly contemplates gunshot or splinter injuries “sustained accidentally” while carrying out operations against the enemy or militants, as well as injuries caused by firing by own troops. In either case, the injury must occur during the relevant operations. The Court found that Singh’s case fell within the first limb.

It further held that the surviving field and medical records, including the Severity Certificate, met both requirements under Paragraph 69 of the Army Order: the operational circumstances and the grievous nature of the injury.

The missing digital entry and the destruction of original documents in floods while they were in official custody could not, the Court said, defeat a claim supported by surviving official records. An accident officially recorded as such could not be treated as self-inflicted merely because the weapon belonged to the soldier, and Singh should not be made to bear the consequences of records lost through no fault of his own. The Bench also noted the authoritative weight of contemporaneous casualty certificates, consistent with the principle in Union of India v. Saroj Devi.

Relief ordered

The Court set aside the Tribunal’s judgment of 10 May 2023 in O.A. No. 1066 of 2022 and its order of 19 July 2023 in M.A. No. 1034 of 2023. It directed that the War Injury Element be paid from Singh’s date of retirement under Regulation 103, with the Disability Element already disbursed deducted to prevent double payment. The Union must issue the revised PPO and pay the net arrears within three months.

The ruling clarifies that an accidental discharge of a serviceman’s own weapon during operational duty against militants or the enemy is not automatically excluded from War Injury Element eligibility as self-inflicted. It also confirms that a claim may be established through genuine surviving field records even when primary files have been lost in official custody or a later digital database is incomplete. Where official documents establish the operational connection and nature of the injury, the Court said, pension benefits cannot be denied solely on restrictive or technical grounds.

Follow our WhatsApp Channel Follow our Telegram Channel
Back to blog

Leave a comment